First Responders 04

Brett J. Overmyer

July 17, 1961 ~ July 28, 2019 (age 58)

Obituary Image


Brett J. Overmyer, 58 of Rochester, Indiana; formerly of Cicero, Indiana died on July 28, 2019 at 7:23 p.m. at his residence. On July 17, 1961 in Plymouth, Indiana he was born to Donavon Overmyer and Julia (McKee) Overmyer. He had lived in Rochester, Indiana the past 2 years, having lived in Cicero, Indiana for 35 years. Brett grew up in the Culver community.

On August 15, 1992 in Culver, Indiana he married Lisa Lynn Gochenour.

Brett was a Fireman with the Carmel Fire Department, Carmel, Indiana. He retired as a Captain in 2007 after 22 years with the department. He currently is self-employed with Overmyer Consulting doing Home Inspections. 

Brett was a graduate of Culver High School with the class of 1980, and obtained an Associate Degree from Indiana Wesleyan University.

Brett is survived by his Wife – Lisa Overmyer of Rochester, Indiana

Daughters – Natalie Brand and husband Julien of Westfield, Indiana; Samantha Keen and husband Shane of Walton, Kentucky; and Baylee Overmyer of Rochester, Indiana

Son – Mitchell Overmyer of Fort Wayne, Indiana

5 Grandchildren    

Brothers – Cortland Overmyer and wife Carol of Dorr, Michigan; Thomas Overmyer and wife Diana of Culver, Indiana; Ned Overmyer and wife Barb of Rochester, Indiana; and his twin brother Brian Overmyer and wife Jodie of Argos, Indiana

He is preceded in death by his Parents

Memorial Contributions may be made to: Fulton County Animal Center and Shelter; 1540 N. Wentzel St., Rochester, Indiana 46975






To send flowers to the family or plant a tree in memory of Brett J. Overmyer, please visit our floral store.


Private Services


Fulton County Animal Center
1540 Wentzel Street, Rochester IN 46975

© 2020 Earl-Grossman Funeral Home. All Rights Reserved. Funeral Home website by CFS & TA